Contributory Liability Is an Increasingly Outdated Clause
Brunswick, GA (Law Firm Newswire) September 5, 2012 – For the past decade in Maryland, plaintiffs have been barred from recovering medical liability damages if they were found to have contributed to their injury.
All of that could change, as Maryland’s high court has agreed to examine that state’s contributory liability clause, which states that parties found even partly responsible for being harmed may not collect damages from another culpable party.
The legal dispute prompting the examination started when a Maryland-based assistant soccer coach swung from a goal post, which then fell on him, causing multiple facial injuries. He sued the local soccer association, claiming that representatives failed to properly inspect and secure the goal post and failed to warn him about the potential danger of swinging from it.
In 2011, jurors found in favor of the plaintiff, deciding that the soccer association’s negligence caused his injuries. However, they also found that the plaintiff’s actions did contribute to his accident. Maryland has a contributory negligence clause, which prevented the plaintiff from receiving any award.
During the plaintiff’s appeal, his attorney argued that contributory negligence is an “antiquated doctrine” and should be changed to comparative negligence, which would allow jurors to decide the level of responsibility of each party and then allocate the appropriate amount of liability to each side. The Court of Appeals of Maryland has agreed to review the case, although a date for oral arguments has not yet been scheduled.
“What we tend to see when contributory negligence is applied is unfair verdicts,” said Brunswick personal injury attorney Nathan Williams. “Comparative negligence, on the other hand, is a way to match responsibly and fault. For example, the plaintiff could be considered 15 percent at fault, while the soccer association is deemed 85 percent liable. The damage award would be adjusted or reduced, depending on the level of responsibility.”
Currently, the contributory negligence clause is used in Alabama, the District of Columbia, Maryland, North Carolina and Virginia, while other states apply comparative negligence. Meanwhile, physicians argue that uprooting the law would allow patients to recover significant damages, even when their own lack of compliance aided their outcome.
Nathan Williams is a Brunswick divorce attorney, Brunswick personal injury lawyer, Brunswick criminal defense attorney and Brunswick DUI lawyer in Southeast Georgia. Visit http://www.thewilliamslitigationgroup.com or call 1.912.264.0848.
The Williams Litigation Group
5 St. Andrews Court
Brunswick, GA 31520
Toll Free: 877.307.4537
View Larger Map
- Distracted Driving Is Just As Dangerous As They Are Telling You It Is
People tend to text on their cell phone while they drive because they think they are better at multitasking than they really are. But studies about distracted driving continue to prove that people vastly overestimate how well they can manage multiple tasks and grossly underestimate how easily they can become distracted. Researchers studied how well distracted drivers can respond to a changing environment, such as driving while texting, or driving while carrying on a conversation. Their study confirmed that people are not only worse than they think at juggling multiple visual distractions – they also seriously overestimate their overall ability [...]
- Children and Car Safety With Buckle Up for Life
A new program, Buckle Up for Life, is working to educate parents about car safety. Funded in part by automaker Toyota, Buckle Up is working with communities nationwide to get parents to correctly restrain their children in car seats according to safety and manufacturing standards. The program runs six weeks, and covers car seat and booster seat placement, safety and injury concerns. The Buckle Up program also distributes car seats to attendees, and experts demonstrate the correct way to install car seats and booster seats with child safety restraints and seatbelts. According to researchers at the University Of Michigan, in [...]
- Distracted Driving Causes Accidents
According to crash statistics available from The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), distracted driving continues to be an ongoing issue throughout the U.S. Recent data from the NHTSA indicates a steady, nationwide increase in incidents of text messaging while driving, despite laws prohibiting the same. Meanwhile, a new report by US Mobile Data Market, Update Q3 2012, suggests that there has been a drop in the number of texts sent each month by users via cell phone, from an average of 699 texts sent during the second quarter of 2012, to just 678 in the third quarter. While some [...]