» Another Supreme Court Rules Medical Malpractice Caps are Unconstitutional

Another Supreme Court Rules Medical Malpractice Caps are Unconstitutional

Cleveland, OH (Law Firm Newswire) October 5, 2012 - Caps on non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases are being struck down slowly but surely in various states.

Mellino Robenalt LLC has Cleveland Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Attorneys

Mellino Robenalt LLC has Cleveland Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Attorneys

“Missouri’s Supreme Court has recently ruled that the cap on pain and suffering damages in a medical malpractice case, which is set at $350,000, is unconstitutional, as it deprives patients/victims of their right to a trial by jury. It’s about time rulings like this are being handed down,” said Christopher Mellino, a Cleveland medical malpractice lawyer of Mellino Robenalt LLC, in Ohio. “For those who strongly believe in constitutional rights, this decision is welcomed with open arms.”

The Court’s opinion included a bit of history relating to the Missouri Constitution of 1820, which in a nutshell, stated residents of Missouri had a common law “right” to ask for damages for medical malpractice. To limit damages is to limit a jury’s fact finding function, which is in violation of the constitutional right to trial by jury.

The case involved a mother whose son was born with catastrophic brain damage. The doctor in charge of the delivery delayed an emergency C-section. At trial, the jury awarded the boy $1.45 million for pain and suffering. The award was reduced by the judge to $350,000, in accordance with Missouri’s cap for medical malpractice cases. “On appeal, this decision was overruled,” explained Mellino.

“What was the reaction of the state medical association? It was not impressed, with their president suggesting the decision turned the clock back to a time when there was a medical malpractice lawsuit crisis. On reflection, if there was a crisis, it only developed because there ‘was’ medical malpractice present. So, really, they have that backwards, particularly when it comes to patient rights,” Mellino remarked.

Statistics released by the Missouri Medical Association revealed that since their medical malpractice law had been enacted, in 2005, lawsuits dropped by just about 58 percent, and there had been an influx of roughly 1,000 doctors, and that medical malpractice insurance premiums had dropped almost $27 million.

“The reason they dropped,” Mellino suggested, “may be less likely due to the cap and more likely due to the fact that with the cap, patients could not get justice and could not sue for fair damages, and thus had to try and cope on their own, at a significant financial disadvantage. In light of this recent decision, medical malpractice patients now have the chance to sue for injuries caused by medical negligence, and that is a good thing.”

To learn more or to contact a Cleveland malpractice attorney, visit http://www.christophermellino.com.

Mellino Robenalt LLC
200 Public Sq., Suite 2900
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Call: (216) 241-1901

  • Product Liability Laws & Injuries from Lawnmowers, Weedeaters, & Grills
    Spring is here and with warmer weather, it’s natural for people to get out of the house, grill, and care for their lawn. However, heavy equipment like lawnmowers, weedeaters, and grills have a potential to cause injury for the user. If an individual is injured as a result of using one of these products, who […]
  • How Social Media Can Destroy Your Personal Injury Lawsuit
    About eight out of every 10 people in the U.S. use some type of social media, including Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Instagram and Pinterest. By the end of 2016, Facebook alone had nearly 2 billion active monthly users worldwide and Twitter logs about 328 million users each month. That’s a lot of people ready and waiting […]
  • What to Do If Your Skin Cancer Was Misdiagnosed?
    Skin cancer is one of the most commonly diagnosed forms of cancer. With May being National Melanoma Awareness Month, it’s important to consider cases where skin cancer was misdiagnosed – either because the doctor failed to diagnose at all or diagnosed in error. If your skin cancer was misdiagnosed, here’s what you should know. Signs […]

See other news sources publishing this article. BETA | Tags: , , ,



Get headlines from Law Firm Newswire sent right to your inbox.

* indicates required