Jury Awards $6.1 Million in Florida Bankruptcy Dispute
Brandon, FL (Law Firm Newswire) April 19, 2013 - A Miami jury handed a businessman a huge cash award in his dispute with a bank.
Maury Rosenberg was awarded $6.1 million in a case against U.S. Bank. Rosenberg alleged the bank was trying to collect on his debt by forcing him into involuntary bankruptcy. The jury found that the bank acted in bad faith.
“Forcing a debtor into bankruptcy as a means of trying to collect on a debt is prohibited by federal law,” said Brandon bankruptcy lawyer O. Reginald Osenton.
The verdict includes punitive damages of $5 million and $1.1 million for emotional distress. Rosenberg's attorneys claim the punitive damage award is the largest ever for such a case.
Rosenberg told the Minneapolis Star Tribune that the bank's refusal to settle the case – even after the dismissal of its bankruptcy petition, which withstood two appeals – has ruined him financially.
U.S. Bank maintains they were properly pursuing money owed them and did nothing wrong. Bank spokesman Tom Joyce said they would file post-trial motions and consider appealing the verdict.
Meanwhile, U.S. Bank is continuing with a lawsuit filed against Rosenberg in federal court in Pennsylvania. The suit claims Rosenberg still owes the bank $4.9 million on a personal guaranty.
Rosenberg owned National Medical Imaging, a company that owned and operated 23 outpatient diagnostic clinics. The company's leases of medical imaging equipment were serviced by Lyon Financial Services Inc., part of U.S. Bank.
In 2008, Rosenberg, anticipating reduced insurance reimbursements due to new regulations, wanted to move his company in a new direction. He contacted Lyon and U.S. Bank to ask about restructuring his debt and claims they refused to discuss the matter as long as he was current on his payments. Rosenberg then ceased payments in order to start negotiations.
U.S. Bank said Rosenberg was in default and filed petitions of involuntary Chapter 7 bankruptcy against him and his company. In 2008, a Miami judge threw out those petitions, ruling that the special legal entities created by the bank to hold the debt had no legal standing to file them. The bank lost two appeals of that ruling.
“It is all too common for creditors to push the boundaries of proper and legal action when pursuing debtors,” Osenton added. “Anyone having trouble staying current on their debts should speak with an experienced bankruptcy attorney.”
Osenton Law Office, PA
500 Lithia Pinecrest Road
Brandon, Florida 33511
Call: (813) 654-5777
- Special Limits on Wage Garnishment
In a previous blog post, http://www.brandonlawoffice.com/2016/06/heres-how-much-of-your-wages-can-be-garnished-to-pay-your-debts, we covered the broad limitations that federal and state laws place on wage garnishment. Wage garnishment is when a creditor sues you to have part of your income diverted directly to them to pay your debts. There are certain general limitations on how much of your income may be […]
- Here’s how much of your wages can be garnished to pay your debts
If you do not pay your debts, your creditors may try to take a portion of your income directly from your employer. This is called wage garnishment. Fortunately, there are limits to how much of your income may be garnished so that you can hopefully keep paying your basic living expenses. The limits are based […]
- Another family law reform bill falls to Gov. Scott’s veto pen
Florida Gov. Rick Scott vetoed a contentious bill that would have reformed the state’s alimony system and altered rules on child custody in divorces. The bill would have required judges in divorce proceedings to adopt a premise for approximately equal time-sharing of children between spouses. Judges could adjust the split based on 20 factors listed […]
See other news sources publishing this article. BETA | Tags: attorney, brandon bankruptcy attorney, brandon bankruptcy attorneys, brandon bankruptcy lawyer, brandon bankruptcy lawyers, brandon lawyers, Osenton Law Office, PA, Reginald Osenton, tampa bankruptcy attorney, tampa bankruptcy attorneys, tampa bankruptcy lawyer, tampa bankruptcy lawyers