Normal Faculties In A DUI Case May “Not” Be Impaired, Despite Police Charging A Driver
Lakeland, FL (Law Firm Newswire) May 6, 2013 - Can a driver arrested for DUI who refuses to blow be proven guilty?
“I get this question a lot when people contact me for my help with DUI charges,” indicated Thomas Grajek, a Lakeland criminal defense attorney. “They want to know if they refused to submit to a breath test, how can anyone prove they are guilty. There is a common fallacy that if you don’t blow, the charge has to be dismissed, because a prosecutor can’t prove the driver was over 0.08. This is wrong.”
Under the Florida DUI statue, 316.193, a person is guilty if a prosecutor proves beyond a reasonable doubt that the individual driver the police arrested had a breath test result or level higher than 0.08 at the time they were stopped and arrested. Or, that the driver the police arrested was under the influence of something that impaired their normal faculties.
What is the definition of normal faculties? “Normal faculties may include, but are not limited to an arrested driver’s ability to make judgments, drive, judge distances, talk coherently and walk in a normal manner, barring a physical disability. To prove a driver’s faculties were impaired, a prosecutor would run a copy of the DUI video, if there is one,” Grajek explained.
In some counties in Florida, such as Polk County, the Sheriff’s Office does not videotape DUI arrests, which would open the door to a number of defenses and create a situation where he said/she said, and who is right or wrong? Since there is no visual evidence, any case made would boil down to either the physical evidence of a breath or blood test, etc., or if the person refused to blow, the officer’s assessment of the person’s normal faculties.
“Without visual evidence, such as a videotape, the prosecutor has the officer testify relating to the indicators of impairment at the time of arrest. That may include the individual’s appearance, if their speech was slurred, how they responded on field sobriety tests and so forth,” explained Grajek.
Only an experienced Lakeland criminal defense attorney knows how to tell the jury that an individual is not guilty of DUI, and he does that by showing that the driver’s normal faculties were not impaired. This may be done in a number of ways, such as referring to a person’s normal driving pattern, that the driver got out of the car without any issues, they performed well on the field tests and did not slur when speaking, etc.
“Also, a case may be defended by pointing out the DUI officer did not take the time to thoroughly explain the field exercises, or wrongly interpreted/graded the driver’s performance, as in not according to the National Highway Safety and Traffic Administration manual,” Grajek outlined. Every driver arrested for DUI is entitled and deserves a vigorous criminal defense. This is not something an individual should attempt to do alone.
Thomas C. Grajek
206 Easton Drive, Suite 102
Lakeland, FL 33803
View Larger Map
A criminal charge involves a criminal complaint, or an “accusatory instrument,” which is the papers filed that accuse someone of committing a crime. There are two delineating criteria factored into considering if a criminal complaint is to be used in a case. One factor looks at whether state or federal laws were broken, which usually determines what court a trial may be held in. Another depends on the nature of the crime and whether it constitutes a serious felony or a less serious misdemeanor. Since different jurisdictions with differing rules and regulations may be involved, it is vitally important to […]
- How to get a hardship license after you have been arrested for DUI.
Today, I was at the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles, Bureau of Administrative Reviews for a Formal Review. Polk County DUI arrests now conduct these hearings telephonically. While there, a person who was just arrested for DUI was trying to “waive” their right to a Formal Review and apply for a hardship license for the entire period of suspension. In a breath test refusal case, this suspension is one (1) year. In an unlawful breath (driver blew over 0.08 legal limit) case, the suspension is six (6) months. This allows a 1st time DUI driver to keep some […]
- Florida sex crime attorney Thomas Grajek on the "sex on the beach" case sentencing
Today the infamous couple convicted of having “Sex on the Beach” are scheduled to be sentenced today. I have previously posted about this case explaining how serious this charge can be at: http://www.flcrimedefense.com/2015/05/florida-couple-found-guilty-of-sex-on-the-beach-and-now-will-be-classified-as-sexual-offenders-and-face-prison-time/ Bay News 9 is reporting that the prosecutor is only seeking 2 1/2 years in prison for the male involved in the case. If the judge agrees to mitigate Jose Caballero’s sentence to that prison sentence, it will be a hug break for him as he is facing a mandatory 15 years in prison. The State can agree to mitigate the sentence which is one of the few […]
See other news sources publishing this article. BETA | Tags: Lakeland criminal defense attorney, Lakeland criminal defense lawyer, Polk County criminal defense attorney, Polk County criminal defense lawyer