Florida Changes Rules to Allow Shorter Yellow Lights, Reaps Red Light Camera Revenue
Tampa, FL (Law Firm Newswire) June 19, 2013 - A change to Florida's rules for traffic signals allowed cities and counties to shorten yellow lights, reaping millions of dollars in fines.
In a recent report, Noah Pransky of Tampa television station WTSP covered the 2011 rule change by the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT), which reduced allowable minimum intervals for yellow lights below the federal government's recommended minimums. State and local traffic engineers then worked together to shorten yellow lights at intersections with red light cameras, the report said.
“Transportation authorities need to find ways to reduce accidents and enforce traffic laws,” said Tampa auto accident lawyer Robert Joyce. “But I'm not sure shortening yellow lights is a great way to go about that. The yellow light is a buffer between intersecting traffic, so this rule change could actually be counterproductive in terms of its effect on safety.”
FDOT had a long-standing rule for calculating minimum yellow light intervals as a function of either the posted speed limit or the 85th percentile of the actual speed of traffic, whichever is greater. But in 2011, the three words “whichever is greater” were struck from the rule, allowing local governments to re-time their signals. Pransky's report alleges that a number of communities shortened their yellow lights, and these changes “typically took place at [red light camera enforced] intersections.”
In an interview with WTSP, an FDOT representative pointed out that it receives no direct revenue from red light cameras and therefore had no financial incentive to implement the rule change. But just over half of citation revenue from red light camera intersections goes to various state funds, including the general revenue fund. Red light cameras generated over $100 million in revenue in 2012 for some 70 Florida communities.
Two reports from the Federal Highway Administration (FHA) said that cities should not use the posted speed limit in calculating yellow light intervals and instead use the 85th percentile speed. This reduces red light violations and severe crashes. The US Department of Transportation recommends adding an extra half-second to yellow lights at intersections with a lot of elderly drivers. But despite the greater Tampa Bay area containing five of the nation's 12 oldest counties, it also has some unusually short yellow lights.
“If a traffic signal is programmed improperly and that contributes to an auto accident, that could be the basis for a lawsuit against the governmental body responsible for the signal,” added Joyce.
Joyce and Reyes Law Firm, P.A.
307 S Hyde Park Ave,
Tampa, FL 33606
View Larger Map
- Florida Supreme Court Sets Arguments in Medical Malpractice Case
The Florida Supreme Court agreed to hear arguments in December on a constitutional challenge to a 2013 medical malpractice law. The Justices agreed to take up the issue of “ex parte communications” in medical malpractice cases. In a case filed by Emma Gayle Weaver, the representative of Thomas E. Weaver’s estate, in Escambia County, the […]
- Family of Corey Jones files Florida wrongful death lawsuit
The family of a man killed by a Florida police officer has filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the officer and the city of Palm Beach Gardens. Corey Jones, a 31-year-old African-American man who was employed as a property manager and played drums in his church, was killed by Palm Beach Gardens police officer Nouman […]
- Fatal Florida car accident raises concerns about safety in autonomous vehicles
The rapidly developing technology of self-driving cars holds the promise of an enormously positive impact on public safety, with many experts claiming that over 90 percent of car accident fatalities could be eliminated if autonomous vehicles become widespread. However, that claim was called into question recently, when it was revealed that the driver of a […]