U.S. Supreme Court Declines to Overturn Rulings Allowing Wrongful Death Lawsuits Against Nursing Homes
Chicago, IL (Law Firm Newswire) June 13, 2013 – The U.S. Supreme Court declined to overturn two rulings allowing wrongful death lawsuits against nursing homes, including an Illinois case.
The Illinois case involves Joyce Gott, who died while under the care of Odin Healthcare Center, a residential nursing home in Odin, Illinois. Gott's daughter, Sue Carter, filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the nursing home. The nursing home argued that because Carter had signed an arbitration agreement on her mother's behalf, she should not be allowed to bring a wrongful death suit in court. The Illinois Supreme Court allowed the wrongful death lawsuit to proceed, and the U.S. Supreme Court has now declined to hear the case.
Both the plaintiff and her mother had signed an agreement with the nursing home stating that “all disputes against each other” where the amount in controversy is $200,000 or greater would be submitted to binding arbitration, including any disputes involving alleged personal injury or improper or inadequate care. When Carter filed a wrongful death and survival act lawsuit, Odin Healthcare moved to compel arbitration of both claims.
The Illinois Supreme Court rejected Carter’s argument that there was no mutuality of obligation in the arbitration agreement. It thus held arbitration must be compelled for claims for negligence or statutory violations that occurred while Gott was living. However, the court ruled that the wrongful death claim was not arbitrable. Because Carter signed the arbitration agreement only as her mother's legal representative, and not in her capacity as special representative on behalf of Gott’s next of kin, the court held that she was not a party to the arbitration agreement.
Briskman Briskman & Greenberg
351 West Hubbard Street, Ste 810
Chicago, IL 60654
Facebook: Like Us!
Google Places: Contact a Chicago personal injury lawyer from Briskman Briskman & Greenberg on Google Places!To learn more, contact a Chicago personal injury attorney or Chicago car accident lawyer at Briskman, Briskman & Greenberg by calling 312.222.0010 or visiting http://www.briskmanandbriskman.com.
- Ford and Nissan Announce Recalls and Obama Administration Proposes NHTSA Budget Increase – Podcast
Ford and Nissan are collectively recalling almost a million trucks and vans. Plus the Obama administration proposes a budget increase for the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on this month’s Chicago Injury Alert.
- Chicago Bicyclist Fatalities Increase in 2014
Last year in Chicago, seven bicyclists were killed in collisions with automobiles. That is an increase from three bicyclist fatalities in 2013, even as Mayor Rahm Emanuel has pledged to make Chicago the most bike-friendly city in the country. According to the Chicago Department of Transportation, bicyclist fatalities over the past five years were as ...
- The attack on workers’ compensation
Over the past decade, workers’ compensation benefits have deteriorated across the country as states initiate cost-cutting measures. A comprehensive new investigation by ProPublica and NPR reveals that these workers’ comp “reforms” have had a brutal effect: injured workers denied the help they need and taxpayers forced to bear the cost of workplace accidents. The ProPublica ...
- $20.6 million jury award upheld in birth injury case
A final appeal has been rejected by a state supreme court, allowing the plaintiffs in a birth injury lawsuit to receive a jury award of $20.6 million to care for their son, who has severe disabilities. The original verdict, in 2012, found that events during the child’s delivery caused oxygen deprivation, resulting in his disabilities. ...