Expert Witnesses May Become Harder to Line Up
Cleveland, OH (Law Firm Newswire) July 16, 2013 – Another set of changes to medical malpractice rules has been passed in Florida.
“Each time a state trots out more legislation to change medical malpractice rules, it’s a fair bet medical negligence victims end up taking the brunt of the changes,” indicated Christopher Mellino, a Cleveland medical malpractice lawyer.
The most recent legislative addition to the Florida legal landscape is SB 1792, that mandates that an expert witness called for the plaintiff in a medical malpractice case must practice precisely the same kind of medicine as the defendant. They can no longer be in similar fields. “Rather than helping a plaintiff, this piece of legislation effectively limits the pool of expert witnesses that are available to testify in a trial,” Mellino explained. Further, the bill permits, but does not mandate, that other health care professionals called to court may violate patient confidentiality and provide the defendant’s lawyer with details about a plaintiff’s care and treatment.
“Although this supposedly only applies to the fact-finding preliminary process of gathering information about the case, it is questionable whether or not that would be adhered to once an actual lawsuit has been filed,” added Mellino.
The legislation states that once a suit is filed, state court rules then restrict who lawyers may talk to and what kinds of questions they may ask. That process may become redundant if attorneys may question virtually anyone they choose in the initial stages of pre-filing. “This kind of legislation opens the door for invading the privacy of medical records,” said Mellino. It appears the legislative changes present more hurdles and barriers for medical malpractice victims, making it harder for them to hold a medical professional accountable for an error and to find true justice.
Many states, in an effort to address controversial measures touted by tort reform, have brought various laws into effective that directly impact the quality of justice available to a medical negligence victim. “Those individuals are entitled to justice and fair compensation,” Mellino pointed out. “They trusted a medical professional who forever changed their lives. They must be held accountable for their errors.”
Mellino Robenalt LLC
200 Public Sq., Suite 2900
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Call: (216) 241-1901
- Surgeon Admits Mistake, Hospital Insurer Denies It
Last summer, a 74-year-old woman fell and broke several vertebrae due to osteoporosis. She underwent spinal fusion surgery but started suffering leg spasms, according to bostonglobe.com. “A doctor recommended she have a pump stitched underneath her skin to get calming medication directly to her spine, and out to her muscles, faster — often a two-hour outpatient procedure,” the August 31, 2014, article stated. “In the operating room [months later], the neurosurgeon requested a special dye to test the location of tubing that had been threaded into her spine. But the pharmacy didn’t have it and provided a different one.” The […]
- Family Files Lawsuit After Camera Catches Home Healthcare Aide Abusing Stroke Victim
Two home healthcare aides working for the same company abused a 78-year-old, 115-pound stroke victim, according to an NBC News affiliate August 21, 2014. His family installed surveillance cameras after he told them about the first aide abusing him. In April, his wife checked the camera footage, called police, and filed a lawsuit against Personal-Touch Home Care after coming home one day to a bruised, depressed, and frightened husband. Video footage revealed that he’d been grabbed, slapped, and force-fed. “No one should be treated like that,” the family’s elder abuse attorney said. “This company is supposed to be sending trained […]
- Black Box Could Prevent Surgical Errors But Doctors Fear Lawsuits
In 2001, telegraph.co.uk reported that researchers were developing a black box for the operating room. Usually, one hears about a black box after an airplane crash, when investigators comb the accident scene for clues as to what went wrong during the flight. In the OR, the black box would record the surgery, including who was involved and how long they were in the room. [Currently, a heart surgeon faces multiple medical malpractice lawsuits for allowing an assistant to finish surgery while he took an early lunch.] “Warning systems on equipment could be improved and extended, and it would be possible […]