Mellino Robenalt States Statue Of Limitations Filing Date May Be A Moving Target In Medical Malpractice Cases
Cleveland, OH (Law Firm Newswire) September 2, 2013 – This case involved a man who apparently received unnecessary heart surgeries. He was caught in the middle of a health care fraud case.
“Although this reported case, Julian Peacock et al. v. Peninsula Regional Medical Center, et al., took place in Maryland, the court’s decision does have ramifications for other jurisdictions,” said Tom Robenalt, a Cleveland medical negligence lawyer with Mellino Robenalt. The court declined to toss a medical malpractice lawsuit out of court filed by a husband and wife who were told that the husband’s numerous heart stent surgeries were necessary, but were then informed by the Department of Justice (DOJ) that they were not necessary and were part of a criminal investigation of their doctor for health care fraud.
The medical center and the defendant doctor asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit, saying the plaintiff waited too long to file it. The federal trial court did not agree. They stated dismissing the case would be premature, as the facts of the case were questions for a jury to resolve.
The lawsuit alleged that the named defendant doctor, his medical group, the regional medical center and the regional health system, performed unnecessary heart procedures on the plaintiff. The defendant doctor is in federal prison serving a term for criminal health care fraud relating to heart procedures he performed between 2003 and 2006.
The plaintiff in this case went to the local E.R. in 2004 with nausea, vomiting and chest pains. The defendant doctor did a catheterization and inserted a stent into his heart. Two months later, the plaintiff had another operation and three stents were placed in his heart. He returned in October of the same year for another catheterization. Then, in 2006 he was given an angioplasty and another stent.
Subsequently, the plaintiff found out about the doctor being investigated for fraud. He called a special number to find out if his surgeries had been unnecessary. He was told his operations were necessary and he chose not to speak with an attorney at that time. He then got a letter from the DOJ saying his stent operations were unnecessary. “At that point, he filed a lawsuit in August of 2012, stating negligence, loss of consortium, lack of informed consent and fraud by intential misrepresentation,” Robenalt explained.The defendants argued the suit was barred by the statute of limitations for medical malpractice, in that a case must be filed five years from the time the injury was committed, or three years from the date the injury was discovered.
“The federal court denied all motions brought by the defendants and asserted the plaintiff had demonstrated enough evidence that a jury could see they were defrauded by the doctor and that the physician had hidden the plaintiff’s medical condition in order to perform more surgeries to obtain more money from the health system,” Robenalt added. The lesson in this case is that not all provisions of a statute of limitations may apply, depending on the circumstances of the case.
Mellino Robenalt LLC
75 Public Square #1020
Cleveland, OH 44113
19704 Center Ridge Rd.
Rocky River, OH 44116
- Anesthesia Mistake Attorney Chris Mellino Wins $3 Million Judgment for Patient
Despite the fact a drug allergy was documented on the patient’s medical chart, the defendant administered Scopolamine, which is similar in molecular structure and in the same class of drugs as the one to which the patient was allergic. “Not only that,” says Christopher Mellino, “they were completely caught off-guard when [the patient] went into anaphylactic shock. The anesthesia doctor wasn’t even in the room when she stopped breathing.” According to the complaint filed in the court of Common Pleas in Cuyahoga County, the mother of two “has experienced permanent and substantial physical and emotional pain and suffering, disability, was […]
- Doctors Need to be Aware of Peripartum Cardiomyopathy in Expectant Mothers
Cardiomyopathy refers to a weak heart muscle that is unable to properly transport blood through the mother’s body. Without enough oxygen, the lungs, liver, and other vital organs are seriously affected. This condition, according to the National Institute of Health (NIH), is seen in approximately every one in 1,300 to 4,000 deliveries. More often than not, it occurs in women over the age of 30. Peripartum cardiomyopathy is often discovered during the last few weeks of a pregnancy but may be diagnosed within five months of delivering the baby. A physician can diagnose the condition during a regular pregnancy check, […]
- Birth Asphyxia and Brain Damage: How Oxygen Deprivation Can Lead to Injury
Birth asphyxia (a lack of oxygen to the brain prior to or during birth) can lead to serious brain damage. Oxygen deprivation can occur during birth for many reasons. As such, it is crucial that medical personnel identify and address the situation in as swift and capable a manner as possible. Correct diagnosis and treatment may, in some cases, lessen the negative effects of a lack of oxygen to the brain. Those who suspect that a medical mistake caused brain damage are welcome to contact our Cleveland office for a free consultation. You may also download or request attorney Chris Mellino’s free […]