Nurse Tosses Donated Kidney Into Garbage Before Surgery
Cleveland, OH (Law Firm Newswire) October 29, 2013 - The outcome of medical malpractice lawsuits may be affected by which hospital is being sued.
“This well known reported case involved an operating room nurse that threw out a kidney about to be donated to a recipient. The transplant organ was thrown in the garbage as medical waste and the woman about to receive the organ from her brother, woke up without her new kidney. She did receive a transplant three months later in another state,” recounted Christopher Mellino, a medical malpractice lawyer in Cleveland, Ohio with Mellino Robenalt LLC.
The upshot of this gong show was that the family filed a medical negligence lawsuit, suing the hospital for up to $1 million for emotional distress, lost wages, pain and suffering, medical bills, and other quantifiable out-of-pocket expenses. There is not much question the lawsuit would be successful in a court. The real issue revolved about the location of the egregious tort, a hospital considered to be a part of the state government. “Which meant, the most the patient and her brother could each be awarded, was $250,000. Furthermore, because the hospital is affiliated with the state, a plaintiff may not seek punitive damages either. If this incident had happened in a private facility, the outcome would be different,” Mellino explained.
In Ohio, the medical malpractice cap, instituted under an anachronistic concept called tort reform, limits the recovery of a victim. Tort reform is blatantly unfair and penalizes a victim twice ---- once at the hands of a negligent medical professional and once at the hands of what should be justice in the courts, but is not. In essence, the law caps non-economic damages at $250,000/person.
“Anyone who suffers a life-altering injury at the hands of a negligent doctor knows that $250,000 does not even begin to touch the medical bills they face for the rest of their life,” said Mellino. Due to the fact the defendant is the state of Ohio, the case is slated for an Ohio Court of Claim judge in Columbus, and not a local jury.
In 1987 when tort reform went into effect, $250,000 then was far more than it represents now, some 26-years later. It was passed to protect universities in the public domain. The issue is the cap is not even indexed to inflation and is a mere pittance in cases such as this one. “However, if this case were tried under a wider ranging law, the medical negligence law passed in 2005, dealing with catastrophic body part losses, non-economic damages could hit $500,000/person, and the hospital could face up to $1 million in non-economic liability,” Mellino outlined.
Mellino Robenalt LLC
75 Public Square #1020
Cleveland, OH 44113
19704 Center Ridge Rd.
Rocky River, OH 44116
- Medical Malpractice and Cerebral Palsy
Cerebral palsy, or CP, is a neurological condition that causes lifelong problems with movement, muscle tone, or posture. Some people with CP also have trouble with hearing, vision, speech, intellectual development, and other functions of the nervous system. When a doctor examines your child, any symptoms your child has may be classified by: Is the […]
- Trick Or Treat? Ensuring Your Child’s Safety This Halloween
According to the Safe Kids Worldwide research, children are twice as likely to be killed by a car while walking on Halloween night than at any other time of year. So what can you do to keep your child safe during this highly anticipated holiday? Here are a number of basic safety guidelines: Use reflective […]
- Warren Ohio family receives $28.7 million verdict in lawsuit brought by their attorney Christopher Mellino over birth injury
A young family was awarded $28.7 million, believed a record amount, in Trumbull County Common Pleas Court. The couple’s son was born in 2010 with cerebral palsy as a result of oxygen deprivation during birth. The family was represented by Christopher Mellino, founder and managing partner of the Mellino Law Firm. The award is to […]