Trucker Faces 20 Counts Of Negligent Injury And One Count Of Negligent Homicide For Rear-Ending School Bus
Austin, TX (Law Firm Newswire) October 7, 2013 – Not all injury lawsuits get to court and get heard without complications.
“This case breaks down into two different trials ---- a civil, personal injury trial and a criminal trial for the charge of negligent homicide. Nonetheless, the two actions do overlap when it comes to evidence and how it is presented in court,” said Bobby Lee, of Lee, Gober & Reyna, Austin, Texas.
One early morning in December 2010, a school bus was stopped by the side of the highway with its lights flashing and stop arm extended. The stretch of highway was straight and level, with no construction in sight, when a trucker slammed into the rear of the bus with such force, that it crumpled the frame right to the back wheels. One injured child had to be cut out of the wreck. Twenty-one kids, ranging in age from 5-years-old to 17 were hurt. Three critically and one 5-year-old died as a result of her injuries.
The bus driver saw the truck coming and did what he could to save lives by telling the kids to get down, brace themselves and hold on tight. He then struggled to keep the bus under control once it had been hit.
The negligent homicide prosecution team was handed a set back when a court of appeal ruled they could not use the medical information of all the students hurt in the 2010 crash. The court stated the records would not be relevant to the homicide case in specific. “However, the District Attorney’s Office would likely use those records if they chose to press on with the 20 negligent injury misdemeanor charges,” added Lee. More specifically, the rest of the records would be prejudicial to the defendant.
“When trying cases such as this one, anything and everything has the potential to go in a direction you do not expect,” indicated Lee, “and for this reason, we try to cover every possible outcome with a plaintiff. Even though a defendant is viewed as being culpable and perhaps even admitted responsibility, they are entitled to a full-fledged and well-thought out defense.”
Would the office of the District Attorney appeal the ruling? That would depend on whether or not there is anything they perceive to be open for an appeal. “Would this type of ruling make a difference to the outcome of the case? It may,” said Lee, “but that largely depends on the type of evidence presented by the plaintiff, his attitude and demeanor, whether he had any prior record of speeding or a history of accidents on the job, what specifically caused this accident, such as texting, distracted driving or DUI, and how cooperative he was during the process.”
It is rare that a personal injury case is open and shut, and not disputed for some reason or another. Since cases involve humans under enormous stress, memory recall is often poor, eyewitness reports may not be accurate, emotions run high and guilt and the evasion of truth are often the order of the day. “As an injury lawyer with many years practice behind me,” indicated Lee, “it never gets any easier to see cases like this. Plaintiffs are devastated and trying to hold it together and hoping justice will out. That is my job. Our office does not back down in any case.”
Lee, Gober & Reyna
11940 Jollyville Road #220-S
Austin, Texas 78759
- Vaginal mesh implant lawsuits continue to be filed
Kentucky’s attorney general just recently filed a lawsuit in Franklin Circuit Court against Johnson & Johnson (J & J) and their medical device subsidiary. It alleges deceptive marketing of vaginal mesh implants according to the state’s consumer protection act. Over 15,000 women in Kentucky received vaginal mesh implants. Allegedly, the company told doctors their mesh kits had been approved by the FDA. However, they had only been cleared. Kentucky is not the only state filing a lawsuit against J & J. California and Washington have also filed suits for similar reasons. The lawsuit alleges that J&J deliberately withheld vital information […]
- Bars may be held responsible for serving customers who DWI
Texarkana’s Fat Jack’s Oyster and Sports Bar and Hopkins Icehouse are facing two civil lawsuits as a result of a fatal 2013 drunk driving accident that killed two. Court documents allege Chad Caldwell consumed 20 beers and several cocktails at two different locations the night of the accident. The at fault party in this case was Caldwell with a blood alcohol level (BAC) of 0.301 when he drove his vehicle into Tameka Pavon’s car. Pavon, who was 38-years-old at the time of the accident and one of two of her passengers in the car died at the scene. The third […]
- Off-duty police officer guilty of DWI for 2012 hit and run fatality
It’s not just ordinary Texas citizens that drink and drive. In this case, an off-duty officer, 49-year-old Raymundo Carranza, ran into 26-year-old Richard Lopez, who was changing a tire at the side of Spur 601, killing him. Carranza left the scene of the accident, only to return two hours later and tell police he thought he had hit something, but did not know what it was. His blood alcohol content was 0.106 three hours after the wreck. The limit where an individual is considered to be legally drunk in Texas is 0.08. Carranza resigned from his job two days after […]
- Drunken Driver Says GPS to Blame for Crash
Police officers hear many reasons why someone was driving while under the influence of alcohol. This excuse however may be reasonably original – bad GPS directions. According to Moody police in Central Texas, a 28-year-old woman crashed into an outdoor picnic pavilion because she got bad directions from her GPS unit. The woman was driving with her 6-year-old son in the vehicle at the time of the crash. Her son sustained minor injuries in the incident. Officers had the driver complete a field sobriety test, which the woman failed, She was charged with DWI, DWI with a child and endangering […]
- Drunk Driver Hits Man Pumping Gas
When you go to fill your car with gas, the last thing you expect is to be hit by a drunk driver. That’s what happened in this case. This accident happened in South Austin on Interstate 35 near St. Elmo Road. Eyewitness say a speeding driver, who was weaving all over the highway, made a sharp turn at the off ramp to miss hitting a concrete divider. Justin Navarrete missed the divider but slammed into a light pole and Kyle Braker and his car. Braker was pumping gas into his vehicle. The victim’s pelvis was fractured and his lungs damaged. […]