Attorney with Briskman Briskman & Greenberg Remarks on Insurer’s Suit to Avoid Defense in $25 Million Worker Death Case
Chicago, IL (Law Firm Newswire) February 17, 2014 – An insurance company is suing to avoid defending a worker death lawsuit.
The dispute arises from a wrongful death lawsuit filed by the family of a construction worker who was buried alive in a workplace accident. State National Insurance Company argues that it has no obligation to defend US-Sino Investment Incorporated, the construction company named as a defendant.
State National has filed a complaint in federal court, claiming that it owes no duty of indemnification to US-Sino or the owner, Richard Xin Liu. The 2012 accident killed Raul Zapata Mercado and led regulators to issue a suspension of the company's contractor’s license.
“Far too many workers are injured or killed on the job all across the country,” observed Robert Briskman, a Chicago work injury attorney. “In the case of a tragic death such as this one, a wrongful death lawsuit may be appropriate to bring some compensation to the family of the victim.”
In January 2012, a 12-foot-deep trench collapsed on Mercado at a Milpitas, California construction site after a three-week period of heavy rain. Mercado's family filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the company a year later, demanding $25 million, including an award of punitive damages.
In the current case, the insurer has pointed to several exclusions that deny coverage for injury claims by contractors or employees in its commercial liability policy with US-Sino.
Another lawsuit has been brought against US-Sino by the owner of the home where the accident took place, claiming that the company failed to resume work after the accident.
State National argues that its policy excludes coverage for both suits. In addition to the exclusion regarding employee actions, the insurer cited other similar clauses, including one for punitive damages.
The insurer also claims that the policy excludes claims arising from “subsidence,” which includes events such as earthquakes, landslides and other earth movements.
The lawsuit seeks court orders to establish that the two lawsuits do not give rise to an indemnity obligation from State National. The insurer is also seeking reimbursement for costs already incurred while defending the construction company in the litigation.
Briskman Briskman & Greenberg
351 West Hubbard Street, Ste 810
Chicago, IL 60654
Facebook: Like Us!
Google+ Contact a Chicago personal injury attorney from Briskman Briskman & Greenberg on Google+.
- Neighbors Ask Whether Collision in Chatham Could Have Been Prevented
On the night of Tuesday, September 13th, an 11-year-old girl was struck by an SUV and pressed against a porch in the Chatham neighborhood of Chicago. She was walking into a snack shop in the neighborhood, at 80th and Vincennes, when the accident occurred. She suffered head trauma and could not breathe without assistance. She ...
- State Governments Rolling Back Workers’ Compensation Protections
In Illinois and other states around the country, workers’ compensation is under attack. A recent investigation by NPR and ProPublica found that since 2003, more than 30 states have enacted legislation that either cuts benefits for injured workers, makes it harder to qualify for compensation, or creates obstacles to obtaining medical care. The federal Occupational ...
- Truck Accidents May Become More Likely If Congress Listens To Trucking Industry Lobbyists
In this episode of Chicago Injury Alert, we look at the trucking industry’s involvement with Congress.
- Trucking Industry Lobbies Congress to Relax Safety Rules, Making Truck Accidents More Likely
Even after high-profile accidents put truck safety in the national spotlight, the trucking industry has spent millions of dollars lobbying Congress to increase limits on truck size, relax restrictions on driver rest time, and delay rule-making on testing drivers for sleep disorders. Lobbyists and their allies in Congress often use deceptive means to make dangerous ...
- Most Brain Injuries Are Caused By Something That Will Surprise You
In this episode of Chicago Injury Alert, we look at traumatic brain injury causes.