In Florida Case, Unexpected Medical Downturn Allows Modification of Alimony on Appeal
Brandon, FL (Law Firm Newswire) August 15, 2014 - Florida's Fourth District Court of Appeals (DCA) recently ruled that deterioration in a former spouse's health can usually support a reduction in his or her alimony obligation.
In Garvey v. Garvey, a former husband sought to modify his alimony obligation to his former wife after his multiple sclerosis (MS) began causing significant health problems. The decision hinged on whether the alimony agreement had been made in anticipation of such a turn in his health.
“I think the Fourth DCA made the right decision here,” said Attorney O. Reginald Osenton, who is not involved in the case. “But it's important to note that this ruling was not a foregone conclusion simply because the former husband's health deteriorated. The idea of whether the husband had anticipated his decline in health was key.”
In 2000, the husband had agreed to provide his former wife with permanent periodic alimony of $5000 per month. At the time, he had been living with MS for 14 years. He was still working full time and had been told by a doctor that his MS was benign. However, in 2011, he suffered an MS attack that partially paralyzed him and left him with an assortment of physical, mental and emotional issues. He was unable to remain at his job.
Initially, the trial court denied his petition to modify the alimony agreement on the grounds that he had been told that MS was a very unpredictable disease that could result in permanent and significant disability -- and he had agreed to the alimony with that knowledge. But the Fourth DCA disagreed, pointing out that the alimony agreement was silent regarding the disease and noting the lack of evidence that the parties had considered the possibility that the former husband might become unable to work.
“Anyone who, since entering into an alimony agreement, has experienced a decline in health, particularly in an unexpected way, should speak with their divorce attorney about a modification,” said Osenton.
Osenton Law Office, PA
500 Lithia Pinecrest Road
Brandon, Florida 33511
Call: (813) 654-5777
- Despite decline, Tampa leads big cities in foreclosures
A recent report on national foreclosure statistics paints an improving, but still unfortunate, picture for Tampa, Florida, homeowners. First, the good news. The Tampa-St. Petersburg metropolitan area has seen a 23 percent decline in home foreclosures in the past year — one of the largest decreases among large U.S. cities. Now, the bad news. Despite […]
- Woman’s handwritten note insufficient to revoke will
The heirs of a deceased New York woman received an object lesson in the importance of taking proper, legally enforceable action when altering a will. Some years before Patricia Powers died, she apparently wished to revoke her existing will entirely, and attempted to do so by writing a note to that effect on the will’s […]
- Chapter 13 can help those saddled with student loan debt
A recent story in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette highlights an increasingly common strategy for dealing with unmanageable student loan debt: Chapter 13 bankruptcy. If you have student loans, you may already be aware that those debts cannot be discharged under Chapter 7 bankruptcy liquidation except in very limited cases. Under Chapter 13 reorganization, however, debtors agree […]