Probable Cause and Medical Marijuana Use: A Legal Conundrum for Vehicle Searches
Lakeland, FL (Law Firm Newswire) August 27, 2014 – There are exceptions to police warrant requirements. In some cases, officers can search a person or his or her personal property without a warrant.
“The most common exception allows a vehicle search with probable cause. The main question here is, what kind of facts may lead to probable cause for a search for legal possession of medical cannabis?” said Thomas C. Grajek, a Lakeland criminal defense attorney. “States that have legalized some forms of marijuana possession and/or use are trying to determine when the possession of cannabis triggers probable cause for a search, and the question is becoming more difficult.”
“Probable cause” is a set of circumstances and facts that exist where there is a significant chance that an object or person to be searched is concealing evidence of a crime or other goods prohibited by law. Put another way, probable cause comes into place when law enforcement reasonably expects to find something illegal. For an automobile, the police do not require a warrant if there is good reason to believe there is something illegal in it.
Before some states legalized the use/possession of medical marijuana, if an officer smelled or saw evidence pointing to the use/possession of marijuana, a search was reasonable. Now that medical marijuana is permissible in some states, determinations are far more complex. “However, most medical marijuana statutes only allow users to carry a small quantity. If a person has too much, a medical card would not prevent prosecution,” added Grajek.
Does any evidence of marijuana still trigger probable cause? It might. And according to a California court, a valid card does not erase probable cause for a search already underway.
In People v. Waxler, police approached the defendant’s car. An officer smelled marijuana and saw a cannabis pipe on the front seat. On searching, other drugs were discovered. The defendant then produced his card. At trial, it was suggested the search was questionable because the card was produced, nullifying grounds for a search. While the man’s card did entitle him to carry a small amount of marijuana, there were still grounds to search to find out if the defendant had more drug in his possession than allowed by law as defined by his card. “In other words, the medical marijuana card could be used as a defense at trial, but it could not be used as a bar against search/arrest,” explained Grajek.
Will the increasingly commonplace use of marijuana for medical and recreational purposes in states where it is legal cease to offer probable cause to search, absent other mitigating factors?
Thomas C. Grajek
206 Easton Drive, Suite 102
Lakeland, FL 33803
View Larger Map
- Woman arrested for DUI while wearing a "Hello Kitty" costume. Drink responsibly and be safe this Halloween!
Halloween is almost here and that means candy, costumes, and parties. Remember to be safe and responsible. There are a lot of children out on the streets Trick-or-Treating and drinking and driving at this time of year can be dangerous. Already, on Sunday a woman in Maine was arrested while dressed as “Hello Kitty”. She was stopped for allegedly driving in the wrong lane. It was not clear whether the driver was wearing the Hello Kitty head pictured below found in the car: The driver refused the breath test. In Florida, the police are not allowed to request a […]
- Bartow high school teacher arrested for drugs over the weekend. Was the search legal?
Over the weekend, a Bartow high school teacher was arrested for possession of marijuana and paraphernalia (a grinder). WFLA channel 8 is reporting that Polk County Sheriff deputies allegedly went to the teacher’s house in response to a tip that the teacher was in possession of the marijuana. Once the deputies arrived, they alleged smelled the odor of marijuana and searched the house according to the news report. Because the arrest just occurred, I was not able to get a copy of the actual police report, but there appears to be some issues with this search and whether it was […]
- If you have been arrested, the Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure require you to disclose certain evidence.
If you have been arrested, one of the first things a criminal defense attorney does is file a “Demand for Discovery” and serve it on the prosecutor. This helps prepare the defense of your case by requiring the prosecutor to turn over information and evidence to the defense lawyer. This is an essential tool in the defense of a case because it lets the attorney and defendant know what they are up against, what defenses are available, and where the prosecutor’s evidence is lacking on an essential element of the crime. However, once a defendant chooses to participate in Discovery, […]