» Texas Supreme Court Issues Decision in Oil and Gas Subsurface Trespass Case

Texas Supreme Court Issues Decision in Oil and Gas Subsurface Trespass Case

Austin Oil and Gas Attorney, Gregory D. Jordan

Austin Oil and Gas Attorney, Gregory D. Jordan

Austin, TX (Law Firm Newswire) October 11, 2017 - The Texas Supreme Court issued a decision in a closely watched case regarding whether trespass occurred when an oil and gas production company drilled horizontally through another party’s mineral interest to produce oil and gas from a lease held by the driller. The state high court upheld the opinions of the lower courts and stated that trespass did not occur.

“Horizontal drilling raises unique legal issues, and until the Texas Supreme Court decided this case, it was not entirely clear that a surface estate owner could drill through a subsurface estate in which they held no mineral rights,” said Gregory D. Jordan, an Austin oil and gas attorney with the Law Offices of Gregory D. Jordan.

In the case, Lightning Oil Company v. Anadarko E&P Onshore, LLC, Anadarko obtained a lease for the subsurface mineral rights on the Chaparral Wildlife Refuge, but was not able to use the surface estate of the Refuge to drill wells. The Briscoe Ranch is located just north of the Refuge, with a mineral lease held by Lightning and the surface estate owned by Briscoe Ranch. Anadarko entered into an agreement with Briscoe Ranch to build several well pads on the surface of the property and drill horizontally through the subsurface to reach the minerals under the Refuge, with no “take points” along Lightning’s lease. Lightning filed a lawsuit claiming trespass and tortious interference with contractual relations, seeking a temporary injunction preventing Anadarko from drilling.

In 2014, the trial court denied the request for a temporary injunction and dismissed the case. Lightning appealed to the San Antonio Court of Appeals, which also sided with Anadarko in 2015. In May 2017, the Texas Supreme Court upheld the decisions of the lower courts. The state high court said that while mineral estate holders have the exclusive right to possess and appropriate oil and gas when a lease is in effect, they do not have the right to “possess the specific place or space where the minerals are located.” The Court also found that the small amount of Lightning’s minerals that would be displaced by the drilling was outweighed by the interests of the industry and society in “maximizing oil and gas recovery.”

“The case makes good common sense,” notes Jordan. “To hold otherwise would effectively eliminate certain acreage from potential production.”

Law Offices of Gregory D. Jordan
5608 Parkcrest Drive, Suite 310
Austin, Texas 78731
Call: 512-419-0684


View Larger Map

  • County Worker on FMLA Leave Deemed “Unemployed” Under Texas Unemployment Compensation Act
    The Texas Supreme Court recently concluded that a county employee on unpaid medical leave was “unemployed” within the meaning of the Texas unemployment compensation statute. The court’s ruling is surprising, because it appears to create a right to unemployment benefits for workers who are not actually unemployed as most understand the term. However, all unemployed [...]
  • Court applies foreseeability limitation to catch-all force majeure clause
    A Texas appellate court ruled that a significant downturn in the price of oil is not a force majeure event that excuses non-performance with a promise to drill for oil by a certain date. Reviewing a contract that excused non-performance for several reasons plus a catch-all clause which stated, “any other cause not enumerated herein,” [...]
  • Professors alleging discrimination sue University of Houston-Victoria
    Three business professors at the University of Houston-Victoria (UHV) are alleging discrimination by their former dean in a lawsuit they filed in March. In their lawsuits, associate professors Luh Yu Ren, Chun-Sheng Yu and Jianjun Du argue UHV officials failed to protect them from discrimination and retaliation from Farhang Niroomand, the former dean of the [...]

See other news sources publishing this article. BETA |



Get headlines from Law Firm Newswire sent right to your inbox.

* indicates required