» Florida May Limit Access to Medical Malpractice Records

Florida May Limit Access to Medical Malpractice Records

Tampa, FL (Law Firm Newswire) May 22, 2018 - In 2004, Florida voters approved Amendment 7, giving patients access to all records of medical-care providers’ known as “adverse medical-incident reports.” Recently, however, some have voiced concern surrounding the implementation of the amendment.

As former general counsel to Governor Rick Scott and member of the state Constitution Revision Commission, Tim Cerio feels that even though the 2004 vote found the public in heavy agreement, change is necessary. Cerio, who is currently working alongside the politically-active GrayRobinson law firm, has filed a proposal to alter Amendment 7 to create limits on the records that lawyers have access to for claims against hospitals, doctors and other medical providers.

This proposal would take adverse medical-incident reports and exclude from them the documents that are “protected by federal laws or regulations relating to patient safety quality improvement,” says Cerio. Any access to these reports would not “abrogate attorney-client communications or work product privileges for patients, health care providers, or health care facilities,” he adds.

Cerio claims that his wish is not to overturn the public’s ability to access to these records and that he wants to change the proposal to only slightly limit the accessibility. The adverse medical-incident reports are key to many medical malpractice claims, and any truncation of access would hinder victims’ ability to make cases against doctors who have multiple claims of malpractice against them.

The proposal is based on Cerio’s belief that the original objective of Amendment 7 has been overlooked. With a broadened approach to Amendment 7 that, according to Cerio, was not the initial intention, hospitals are having a difficult time preparing for legal disputes. He says, “There has been a stream of cases that have expanded the impact of Amendment 7 and created an ability for litigants to get information that was not intended. Attorney-client work product is sacrosanct, and for the courts to expand that, I think, is not a good reading of the original intent of Amendment 7.”

There are two extremely conflicting sides to the argument. While case studies express that a hospital withholding documents could allow the defendant to escape seemingly unjustly unscathed, lobbyist Jan Gorrie believes that patient safety should be held as the first priority. Gorrie, who represents hospitals, says, “If your institution didn’t do something right, you want them to take a serious self-examination, which to some degree won’t happen if they don’t have these processes protected.”

The issue is potentially reemerging in the November 2018 ballot for the public to decide what is best for both plaintiffs and defendants of medical malpractice cases. On one side there are the insurance companies and healthcare providers, while on the other there are trial attorneys who want as much access as possible to the victims’ information.

Robert Joyce, a Tampa medical malpractice attorney with the law firm of Joyce & Reyes, said, “Patients have a right to know what they are dealing with. Plaintiffs and their attorneys deserve to have the knowledge necessary to bring a case to justice.”

Joyce and Reyes Law Firm, P.A.
307 S Hyde Park Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call: 813.251.2007

View Larger Map

  • Brandon woman sentenced to 12 years in prison for operating pill mill
    The owner of Family Medical Express Center Inc. in Brandon, Florida received a federal prison sentence of 12 years and 7 months for illegally using her medical clinic as a pill mill. Her co-conspirators handed out prescriptions of almost 6,000 Xanax pills and over 28,000 oxycodone pills. Yolanda Camara, 49, pleaded guilty to drug conspiracy, […]
  • Florida Senior Dies From Heat Stroke After Falling Off Scooter at Nursing Home
    Last July a resident of a Florida assisted living facility fell off her electric scooter in the community courtyard. She was trapped for six hours before she was found by another resident’s family. Her adult children are now suing Harbor Place at Port St. Lucie for wrongful death, claiming that the fall and sun burns […]
  • Physician sentenced to prison after pleading guilty to pill mill conviction
    On February 23, 2017, Dr. Anil Sahijwani pled guilty for illegally prescribing oxycodone, Adderall and other drugs. The Florida Department of Health rescinded the medical license of the 43-year-old doctor after he was sentenced to 45 months in federal prison. Sahijwani’s practice was at Family Medical Express Center, Inc. located in Brandon, Florida. He and […]
  • Nursing home closes after resident attacks another resident
    The question of the elderly’s safety within nursing homes is again in the spotlight with another offense at Good Samaritan Retirement Home in Williston, Florida. A recently exposed video reveals a resident of the Good Samaritan nursing home beating another resident, a helpless 86-year-old with dementia. The video shows the 52-year-old resident punching the other […]
  • Florida toddler dies of meningitis as doctors fail to diagnose
    Last November, Connor Mincey was sent home sick from a childcare center in Miami, Florida. That day, his parents, Donald and Doreen Mincey, took him to a pediatrician where he was diagnosed with a cold. The pediatrician cleared the 22-month-old child to go back to daycare. Connor died on December 3. The two weeks between […]

See other news sources publishing this article. BETA |

Get headlines from Law Firm Newswire sent right to your inbox.

* indicates required