» 2017’s Largest Verdicts and Medical Malpractice Rulings

2017’s Largest Verdicts and Medical Malpractice Rulings

Tampa, FL (Law Firm Newswire) June 21, 2018 -
All over the country, several major medical malpractice rulings took place last year. Included in this is the Florida Supreme Court decision to increase patient privacy as well as another ruling that bars noneconomic damage caps for medical malpractice claims. The U.S. Supreme Court also settled a dispute surrounding nursing homes and arbitration agreements.

In 2017, at least ten medical malpractice cases resulted in settlements over $20 million.

The top verdict of 2017 was an award of $61.6 million in Rhode Island to a patient who had to have his right leg amputated after he was taken off blood thinners. The patient, Peter Sfameni, sued two of his doctors as well as the hospital. He was originally given a judgment of $40 million, but was awarded $21.6 in addition for Rhode Island’s statute on prejudgment interest. This was the biggest medical malpractice judgment in Rhode Island’s history.

In another case, a family with an infant who suffered from brain damage was awarded $46.5 million by a jury in Arkansas this past March. The child had a worsening skin condition that the hospital’s doctors failed to properly treat.

In Pennsylvania, a federal judge awarded parents of a newborn $41.6 million dollars in a medical malpractice lawsuit. A doctor working at a federally funded health clinic was negligent in his use of forceps to deliver the couple’s baby. The act resulted in permanent brain damage in the child.

In Florida, the state Supreme Court determined in November that a 2013 state law was unconstitutionally written as it denied patients’ privacy rights that the Florida Constitution warrants. The law gave doctors preparing for a medical malpractice lawsuit the right to contact and interview the patient’s prior physicians.

A lower court in Florida had decided that the law did not violate the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act. However, the Florida Supreme Court overturned the ruling of the lower court. The justices stated that the previous lack of privacy that patients were experiencing could have deterred some from filing claims.

The high court said, “The ex parte secret interview provisions of [the 2013 law] fail to protect Florida citizens from even accidental disclosures of confidential medical information that falls outside the scope of the claim because there would be no one present on the claimant’s behalf.”

In June, the Florida Supreme Court overturned a 2003 state law surrounding medical malpractice noneconomic damage caps. North Broward Hospital District v. Kalitan, in a 4-3 ruling, determined that the law maximizing noneconomic damages to $500,000 for most or $1 million for the more atrocious cases was a violation of the Florida Constitution’s equal protection clause.

“The court did the right thing in finding these caps on damages unconstitutional,” said Robert Joyce, a medical malpractice attorney with the Tampa law firm of Jocye & Reyes.

Though the Kentucky Supreme court did rule that an individual who had signed an arbitration agreement with an attorney wrongly waives his right as a patient to a jury trial, the U.S. Supreme Court determined in a 7-1 ruling that the Federal Arbitration Act should preempt the state’s arbitration rule. The Federal Arbitration Act states that arbitration agreements should be treated the same as any other contract.

Joyce and Reyes Law Firm, P.A.
307 S Hyde Park Ave
Tampa, FL 33606
Call: 813.251.2007


View Larger Map

  • Types and symptoms of nursing home abuse
    Nursing home abuse and elder neglect is a serious offense. Senior care facilities owe residents a reasonable standard of care. All residents of a nursing home facility deserve to not be neglected and abused. To ensure quality care, nursing homes and their staff should be capable, competent, caring and well trained. Not all homes, however, […]
  • What to do after a car crash
    An automobile accident can be traumatic. Car crashes are jarring and disorienting experiences, especially if you have been injured. However, there are things you should do, right after a car accident. Call 911. The most important thing to do is to call for help. Call 911 as quickly as possible. Even if you are not […]
  • Things to know about medical malpractice claims in Florida
    Medical errors are a huge problem in the United States as well as the State of Florida. Mistakes by medical professionals happen more often than most people realize. Moreover, medical malpractice errors can cause serious and debilitating injuries and conditions that could ruin someone’s life and even end in a fatality. A study performed by […]
  • Brandon woman sentenced to 12 years in prison for operating pill mill
    The owner of Family Medical Express Center Inc. in Brandon, Florida received a federal prison sentence of 12 years and 7 months for illegally using her medical clinic as a pill mill. Her co-conspirators handed out prescriptions of almost 6,000 Xanax pills and over 28,000 oxycodone pills. Yolanda Camara, 49, pleaded guilty to drug conspiracy, […]
  • Florida Senior Dies From Heat Stroke After Falling Off Scooter at Nursing Home
    Last July a resident of a Florida assisted living facility fell off her electric scooter in the community courtyard. She was trapped for six hours before she was found by another resident’s family. Her adult children are now suing Harbor Place at Port St. Lucie for wrongful death, claiming that the fall and sun burns […]

See other news sources publishing this article. BETA |



Get headlines from Law Firm Newswire sent right to your inbox.

* indicates required